By Susan Crossett, CEO, CPS Recruitment
Understanding the costs of hiring will help companies determine which recruiting model works best for them. To make that determination, let’s review the variety of options available and each of their benefits.
Often companies begin with internal recruiting. Filling open jobs from within, using employee referrals, internal advertising, and posting of jobs has several advantages. It is cost effective, provides employees with a potential career path, boosts morale and provides a built-in knowledge base. The downside is the candidate pool is more limited, less diverse and may create gaps in the organization.
External recruiting can mean using a variety of different methods depending on the type of role an employer is seeking to fill. A company with a strong brand may attract enough candidates without needing to use any third-party intermediary. They may maintain a database of good quality candidates that have interviewed for a different role, for future opportunities. Staying connected with alumni who departed in good standing is another way to optimize your candidate database. A robust candidate database helps to minimize hard costs associated with recruiting talent.
In a highly competitive labor market various other tools are available to assist in the recruiting process. A company can start with a simple online classified website, such as Craigslist, a low-cost option that allows employers to choose the location and industry sector to post their ad. Social media jobsites allow for job advertisements and candidate database searching or sourcing, think LinkedIn.
Job Boards are internet-based talent acquisition technologies that aggregate either local, national, or international job offerings. Typically, employers pay up front to advertise the job offering for a set period of time. Job aggregators pull jobs from other sites and use a pay per click pricing model when a candidate applies for a job.
The methods above are relatively low out of pocket costs for talent acquisition. Depending on the type of role, these tools work very well to find candidates. If an employer is seeking to fill a senior executive position, a retained search provided by an executive search firm may be the right approach. A retained search fee is paid up front and usually is paid if a hire was made or not.
Another method for recruitment is using the services of a staffing firm for direct hire, also known as permanent placement. In this method the fee is only paid once a hire has been made and is typically a percentage of the annual salary for the first year. It does not include commissions or bonus plans as part of the fee. According to a recent survey by Staffing Industry Analysts (SIA), the median fee was 25% for a direct hire placement.
Staffing firms also provide temporary or contingent workers to assist employers, for a ramp up, a special project, long-term contracts or to determine if the employee is a good fit for the role. The fee is determined by the overhead costs associated with the role and the mark-up by the staffing firm.
Depending on the role an employer is seeking to fill may well determine which method is used for sourcing a candidate. If the role is customer interfacing or revenue generating, then a more targeted approach with the support of a staffing supplier may be appropriate. If the company does not have a human resources team that includes recruiters establishing a strong relationship with an outside firm that understands the company culture and the types of skills needed for that company, may be the best available option for talent acquisition.
Prioritizing costs vs. efficiency vs. quality will help determine which method best suits your hiring needs.
The Cost of Hiring
Understanding the cost of hiring helps companies decide which recruiting approach works best for them. Let’s explore the key options and their benefits.
Internal Recruiting
Many companies start by filling open roles from within. Internal recruiting uses employee referrals, job postings, and promotions. This method offers several advantages:
- Cost-effective – No external fees involved.
- Career growth – Helps employees see a path forward.
- Boosts morale – Employees feel valued and motivated.
- Built-in knowledge – Candidates already understand the business.
However, the talent pool is limited, reducing diversity, and potentially creating skill gaps if employees move within the organization.
Some companies, especially those with strong brands, can attract candidates without needing third-party services. They may also keep databases of past candidates or maintain relationships with former employees to rehire them when the opportunity arises. Building a strong candidate database lowers recruiting costs in the long run.
External Recruiting
External recruiting opens new ways to find talent.
Online Recruiting Tools
In competitive markets, companies may rely on online tools to reach candidates:
- Classified Sites – Platforms like Craigslist offer low-cost, location-specific postings.
- Social media – Sites like LinkedIn allow companies to post jobs and search candidate databases.
- Job Boards & Aggregators – These platforms, like Indeed, charge upfront or per-click fees, making them scalable options for local, national, or global recruiting.
Executive Search Firms
For senior roles, companies often use retained search firms, which charge a fee upfront regardless of if a hire is made. This is ideal for businesses seeking top-tier leadership but willing to invest more in the process.
Staffing Firms
Staffing firms offer two main services:
- Direct Hire (Permanent Placement) – The fee, typically 25% of the new hire’s first-year salary, is only charged once a successful hire is made.
- Temporary/Contingent Workers – Useful for project-based work, seasonal surges, or contract roles. Fees reflect both the staffing firm’s overhead and mark-up.
Matching the Method to the Role
The best recruiting method often depends on the role:
- Customer-facing or revenue-generating roles may require a targeted approach with the help of staffing partners.
- Companies without dedicated recruiters may benefit from working with staffing firms that understand their culture and talent needs.
Balancing Cost, Efficiency, and Quality
Ultimately, prioritizing costs, efficiency, and quality will guide businesses toward the recruiting model that best fits their hiring goals.
For more information on the cost of hiring and the best option for your firm/company, you may contact Susan Crossett, CEO, CPS Recruitment at 315-883-5470, SCrossett@CPSRecruiter.com or visit online at www.CPSRecruiter.com.
In 2019, the Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act (CLCPA) was passed by the New York State Assembly and the New York State Senate, then signed into law by former Governor Andrew Cuomo. This legislation requires New York State to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 40% in 2030, and 85% by 2050 from 1990 levels. In addition, the CLCPA requires establishing a 100% clean electrical grid by 2040.
It may go without saying, but 2024 continues to be one for the record books when it comes to severe weather events. Even as some of this year’s events have eclipsed past weather events for loss of property and life, it is the cumulative effect of so many events nationwide that is rapidly changing the insurance landscape. The collective cost of losses is resulting in a sea change in both personal and commercial insurance pricing. And as we have seen, these losses are not confined to “traditional” high-risk areas of the country.
I was recently asked to moderate a panel in NYC sponsored by the Mother Cabrini Health Foundation, on the shortage in the nursing workforce.
Clark Equipment Rental and Sales of Canastota celebrates its 20th anniversary next year – an impressive milestone for any business today – and owner Adam Clark is planning for the next twenty. Clark’s origin story began in grade school; through his dedication to customer satisfaction and adapting to changing client needs, he’s built an impressive reputation.
Clark started out working from a storage unit in Syracuse. From there, he moved to a one-acre property with a 3,600-square-foot warehouse. The next move increased the physical space to about six acres with a 7,000-square-foot building.
“When I first started, I was so small, I couldn’t help but get to know customers personally,” Clark said.
“We’ve kept that personal touch,” Clark agreed.
“We have a lot of repeat business because people like our customer service,” Stone said. “Max has a lot of repeat customers thanks to his efforts and everything service does to get equipment ready and help customers once they have it. If they have a problem, we try to help them through it. It’s harder when they’re out of state, but we can still point them in the right direction, whether they need parts or service.”
Newer-model machines without the new equipment price
“It’s easier to manage the inventory,” he said. “I’m very particular about the way my equipment looks and how it’s maintained. With everything in one location, it makes things much easier for my staff and customers.”
“The challenge for me will be managing subsequent locations successfully, then keep rolling them out,” Clark said. “We have between 600 and 700 machines and sell 30 to 50 machines monthly. We rent a few hundred machines every month. The operation is pretty amenable to scaling. I just need a couple more key people – a couple more mechanics and one or two more good over-the-road salespeople. A couple more years of saving my pennies and we’ll open another store. Growing the business is fun.”
Central New York is a region rich in history, culture, and natural beauty. Amidst the picturesque landscapes and vibrant communities, manufacturing stands as a cornerstone of the local economy, driving growth, innovation, and opportunity. As we explore the unique regional economic landscape, one quickly sees that manufacturing plays a pivotal role in shaping our prosperity. And, with the arrival of Micron Technology and its supply chain, the influence of manufacturing will only continue to grow.
In 2019, the Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act (CLCPA) was passed by the New York State Assembly and the New York State Senate, then signed into law by former Governor Andrew Cuomo. This legislation requires New York State to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 40% in 2030, and 85% by 2050 from 1990 levels. In addition, the CLCPA requires establishing a 100% clean electrical grid by 2040.
Despite the on going inflationary environment, workers’ compensation costs are set to decrease for the eighth consecutive year on October 1, 2024. Overall, loss costs and resulting rates will drop by an average of 9% across all class codes. However, this change may vary depending on specific class codes, with some seeing increases and others decreases, but the overall net decrease averages 9%.